A new index to discriminate between iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia trait.

BACKGROUND: The most common microcytic and hypochromic anemias are iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia trait. Several indices to discriminate iron deficiency anemia from thalassemia trait have been proposed as simple diagnostic tools. However, some of the best discriminative indices use parameters in the formulas that are only measured in modern counters and are not always available in small laboratories. The development of an index with good diagnostic accuracy based only on parameters derived from the blood cell count obtained using simple counters would be useful in the clinical routine. Thus, the aim of this study was to develop and validate a discriminative index to differentiate iron deficiency anemia from thalassemia trait. METHODS: To develop and to validate the new formula, blood count data from 106 (thalassemia trait: 23 and iron deficiency: 83) and 185 patients (thalassemia trait: 30 and iron deficiency: 155) were used, respectively. Iron deficiency, ß-thalassemia trait and α-thalassemia trait were confirmed by gold standard tests (low serum ferritin for iron deficiency anemia, HbA2>3.5% for ß-thalassemia trait and using molecular biology for the α-thalassemia trait). RESULTS: The sensitivity, specificity, efficiency, Youden's Index, area under receiver operating characteristic curve and Kappa coefficient of the new formula, called the Matos & Carvalho Index were 99.3%, 76.7%, 95.7%, 76.0, 0.95 and 0.83, respectively. CONCLUSION: The performance of this index was excellent with the advantage of being solely dependent on the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration and red blood cell count obtained from simple automatic counters and thus may be of great value in underdeveloped and developing countries.

A new index to discriminate between iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia trait

BACKGROUND: The most common microcytic and hypochromic anemias are iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia trait. Several indices to discriminate iron deficiency anemia from thalassemia trait have been proposed as simple diagnostic tools. However, some of the best discriminative indices use parameters in the formulas that are only measured in modern counters and are not always available in small laboratories. The development of an index with good diagnostic accuracy based only on parameters derived from the blood cell count obtained using simple counters would be useful in the clinical routine. Thus, the aim of this study was to develop and validate a discriminative index to differentiate iron deficiency anemia from thalassemia trait. METHODS: To develop and to validate the new formula, blood count data from 106 (thalassemia trait: 23 and iron deficiency: 83) and 185 patients (thalassemia trait: 30 and iron deficiency: 155) were used, respectively. Iron deficiency, ß-thalassemia trait and a-thalassemia trait were confirmed by gold standard tests (low serum ferritin for iron deficiency anemia, HbA2 > 3.5% for ß-thalassemia trait and using molecular biology for the a-thalassemia trait). RESULTS: The sensitivity, specificity, efficiency, Youden's Index, area under receiver operating characteristic curve and Kappa coefficient of the new formula, called the Matos & Carvalho Index were 99.3%, 76.7%, 95.7%, 76.0, 0.95 and 0.83, respectively. CONCLUSION: The performance of this index was excellent with the advantage of being solely dependent on the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration and red blood cell count obtained from simple automatic counters and thus may be of great value in underdeveloped and developing countries.

RDW as differential parameter between microcytic anemias in "pure" and concomitant forms / RDW como parâmetro diferencial entre anemias microcíticas nas formas "pura" e em concomitância

Introduction: Iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia minor are microcytic and hypochromic types of anemia commonly found in our environment. The correct differentiation between them is of great clinical importance, although it is often hampered by the coexistence of diseases that may alter the results of standard tests for their discrimination, in addition to the significant costs of such tests. Objective: The objective of this study was to investigate the discriminatory power of red cell distribution width (RDW) between iron deficiency anemia and thalassemia minor. Method: Blood parameters were compared in 227 patients with iron deficiency anemia and/or thalassemia minor after diagnosis confirmed by molecular biology and HbA2 measurement for alpha thalassemia and beta thalassemia trait respectively. The frequency of alpha thalassemia trait in a population from two public hospitals of Minas Gerais was also determined. Result and conclusion: RDW was able to differentiate iron deficiency anemia from thalassemia trait, what indicates that this blood count parameter is a useful tool since concomitant disorders are excluded. In addition, a high frequency of the -α3.7 mutation was observed in the study population (20.3%), justifying its investigation when another cause for microcytic anemia is absent. .

Introdução: A anemia ferropriva e as talassemias menores são anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas comumente encontradas em nosso meio. A correta diferenciação entre essas anemias é de grande importância clínica, embora muitas vezes seja dificultada pela concomitância de doenças que podem alterar os resultados dos exames padrão, além dos custos significativos de tais testes. Objetivo: O objetivo deste estudo foi investigar o poder discriminatório do índice de anisocitose eritrocitária (RDW) entre anemia ferropriva e talassemias menores. Método: Foram comparados os parâmetros hematológicos de 227 pacientes portadores de anemia ferropriva e/ou talassemia menor após diagnóstico firmado por biologia molecular ou por dosagem de hemoglobina alfa 2 (HbA2), no caso de traço alfa ou betatalassêmico, respectivamente. Foi também determinada a frequência das talassemias menores em uma amostra populacional proveniente de dois hospitais públicos de Minas Gerais. Resultado e conclusão: Observou-se que o RDW foi capaz de diferenciar as talassemias menores da anemia ferropriva, indicando que este parâmetro do hemograma é uma ferramenta útil, desde que excluídos distúrbios concomitantes. Além disso, foi verificada uma elevada frequência da mutação -α3.7 na população estudada (20,3%), o que justifica a sua pesquisa na ausência de outra anemia microcítica. .

O papel do RDW, da morfologia eritrocitária e de parâmetros plaquetários na diferenciação entre anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas / The role of RDW, erythrocyte morphology and platelet parameters in the differentiation between microcytic and hypochromic anemias

As anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas atingem grande parcela da população mundial. Entre estas, significativa porcentagem de casos se deve à deficiência do ferro, enquanto em algumas regiões a frequência de talassemia menor se torna importante. Por outro lado, a anemia de doença crônica é a causa mais comum de anemia em pacientes hospitalizados. O diagnóstico diferencial destas doenças é clinicamente importante, e é atualmente realizado através dos exames padrão ouro envolvendo a avaliação do metabolismo do ferro e dosagem de HbA2. Embora dotados de grande utilidade, estes testes podem apresentar uma metodologia mais demorada e onerosa que, em casos de concomitância de doenças, comuns na prática clínica, não conseguem proporcionar um correto diagnóstico. Na tentativa de otimizar e direcionar o diagnóstico destas anemias, o uso de alguns parâmetros derivados dos modernos contadores automáticos tem sido sugerido. Neste estudo, o papel do RDW, parâmetros plaquetários (número de plaquetas, PDW, VPM) e morfologia eritrocitária como parâmetros diferenciadores, foi avaliado em um grupo de 159 pacientes portadores de anemia microcítica e hipocrômica devido à deficiência do ferro, anemia de doença crônica e talassemia beta menor, comprovado pelos exames padrão ouro. Foi possível observar que o RDW não se mostrou um bom discriminante, enquanto o índice plaquetário PDW pode ser um parâmetro auxiliar no diagnóstico diferencial das anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas. Com relação às alterações morfológicas dos eritrócitos, o pontilhado basófilo foi um achado bastante comum apenas em pacientes portadores de talassemia beta menor, com indícios de potencial utilidade na elucidação de casos de microcitose.

Microcytic and hypochromic anemias affect many people worldwide. A significant percentage of cases are due to iron deficiency, while in certain regions the frequency of thalassemia minor is important. On the other hand, anemia of chronic disease is the most common cause of anemia in hospitalized patients. Differential diagnosis between these anemias, currently established by using gold standard tests involving evaluation of iron metabolism and measurement of HbA2, is of clinical importance. Although very useful, these tests are time consuming and onerous. In cases of concomitant diseases, a common finding in the clinical practice, these tests are unable to provide a correct diagnosis. In an attempt to optimize diagnosis of these anemias, the use of some parameters derived from modern automated blood count analyzers has been suggested. In this study, the role of RDW, platelet parameters (platelet number, PDW, MPV) and erythrocyte morphology as differentiating parameters were evaluated in a group of 159 patients diagnosed as carriers of microcytic or hypochromic anemias due to iron deficiency, anemia of chronic disease and â-thalassemia minor, as confirmed by gold standard tests. The RDW did not prove to be a good discriminator, while the platelet index, PDW, may be helpful in the differential diagnosis of microcytic and hypochromic anemias. Regarding the red cell morphologic alterations, basophilic stippling was a quite common finding just in patients with â-thalassemia minor, suggesting it to be a potential marker for elucidating cases of microcytosis.

Índice de anisocitose eritrocitária (RDW): diferenciação das anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas / Red blood cell distribution width (RDW): differentiation of microcytic and hypochromic anemias

A anemia ferropriva, talassemia menor e anemia de doença crônica são as anemias microcíticas e hipocrômicas mais comuns em nosso meio. O diagnóstico diferencial das referidas anemias é de grande importância clínica; contudo, muitas vezes é complexo em virtude de concomitância de doenças, além de demandar tempo e apresentar custos significativos. Com o propósito de conferir maior simplicidade e eficiência ao diagnóstico diferencial destas anemias, o uso de índices derivados de modernos contadores automáticos tem sido sugerido. Entre estes, pode ser citado o índice de anisocitose eritrocitária (RDW), que indica o grau de variabilidade do tamanho das hemácias. Neste estudo, o poder de discriminação deste índice quanto ao tipo de anemia microcítica e hipocrômica foi avaliado em um grupo de 159 pacientes sabidamente portadores de um quadro de anemia causado por deficiência de ferro, beta talassemia menor ou uma anemia de doença crônica. Não foi observada diferença significativa para o RDW entre os três grupos de anemias microcíticas, indicando não ser este índice uma ferramenta útil para a diferenciação entre anemia ferropriva, beta talassemia menor e anemia de doença crônica.

Iron deficiency anemia, the thalassemia trait and chronic disease anemia are the most common microcytic and hypochromic anemias in the Brazilian population. Differential diagnosis of these anemias is of great clinical importance however, frequently, it is complex due to coexistence of diseases, as well as being time consuming and expensive. In order to simplify and increase efficiently of checking the differential diagnoses of these anemias, the use of indexes derived from modern blood cell counters has been suggested. Among them, is the index called red blood cell distribution width which indicates the variability in red blood cell size. In this study, the discriminative power of the red blood cell distribution width in differentiating microcytic and hypochromic anemias was evaluated in a group of 159 patients diagnosed as carriers of either iron deficiency anemia, â-thalassemia minor or chronic disease anemia. No difference was found for the red blood cell distribution width among the three groups of microcytic and hypochromic anemias indicating that this index is not a useful tool to distinguish among iron deficiency, â-thalassemia minor and chronic disease anemia.